Agnostic views & images I like

Thoughts about things on the web

How can ID and a benevolent God allow Tay-Sachs babies?

leave a comment »

Fundus photograph showing retina changes assoc...Image via Wikipedia

Insurance Company Yields in Fight With Parents of a Tay-Sachs Child – New York Times

I don’t usually read this kind of an article. I am squeamish about genetic disorders that affect babies, who seem normal at birth. I am squeamish about rare genetic disorders that affect members of a specific group of people defined by their ethnicity and very specific genetic family. I feel very cowardly about my ability to deal with any comparable disorder/disease affecting me or my family or my friends.

But what is Tay-Sachs?

It does sound like a terrible sentence to pain, suffering and a very short and miserable life for these babies. And of course a terrible genetic retribution that focuses on a small very identifiable ethnic group of human beings. How can this form of genetic disorder be reconciled with Intelligent Design or attribution of the creation of humans to a God, benevolent or not? The dire circumstances for those babies and their parents can only be seen as a quirk of a natural process gone awfully wrong.

I realize that parents of Tay-Sachs babies can and must seek financial relief from whatever source is at hand if they live in an organized developed society. But surely there are similar genetic disorders that zero in on other specific groups of people defined by their ethnic/genetic characteristics. And surely some of these families live in developing and undeveloped economies that don’t offer any, or only very limited, financial or medical resources to deal with such dire human situations.

How can anybody, agnostic, religious or spiritual, reconcile any power in our universe, real or imagined, with so cruel a fate for the babies/children and their birth families? Reconcile or explain away?

In my heart and mind I know that if I had anything to do with this hell-on-earth situation, I would argue strongly for euthanasia as the only reasonable way of ending this kind of unecessary, unbidden and undeserved suffering. Tay-Sachs babies die early in their life. Surely all they know in their frail psyches is pain, suffering and isolation from the normal course of human life – a very human version of hell-on-earth.

And don’t tell me that God has a special place for them in Heaven!


Zemanta Pixie
Advertisements

Written by BobG in Dalian & Vancouver

2006/08/24 at 10:04

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: